Wednesday 15 August 2007

"We live for a moment and then, like the wind, are gone."

Like the character in a strip described on page 818 of this biography, I have just realised that the title Of Margaret Mitchell's (my mother's names both, coincidentally) famous book, 'Gone with the Wind' is a derived from no. 103 of the Psalms. The line stuck in my head after I finished reading the tome. It's one of those classic, grand biographies that give us the subject from cradle to grave, complete. I have vicariously lived Caniff's 81 years condensed into a short span of time, in this case a couple of weeks, starting on my flight back from San Diego where I picked it up. I had waited too long for this book to not start it right away. Shel Dorf mentions it here, way back in 1998: "I tape recorded many of those conversations with his knowledge and loaned the tapes to R. C. Harvey when he was writing Milt's biography; he's still looking for a publisher." Nine years later we have Bob's book in our mitts. Given that the publisher is Fantagraphics, I presume he got tired of sending it around to all the big houses and gave up hope of a monetary advance commensurate with both the labour and the cultural-historical value of the project. And finishing it yesterday morning, in tears inevitably, I had to write off the rest of the day and go and have lunchtime beers with those pals of mine, none of whom have read a single page of the cartoonist I often cite as the single most important influence on my career.

You may say, 'all right, but we can't see any of that in your work, Campbell.' Fair observation.

I first discovered Caniff in the early 1970s, one of that generation who had taken Marvel comic books very seriously and were then looking for something meatier to sink our teeth into. As Harvey shows in his book, this particular cosmic balance came into effect as Caniff's then current Steve Canyon (1947-1988) daily strip was seriously losing circulation. Compilations of his earlier Terry and the Pirates (1934-1946) were starting to appear in collector's editions, first from Nostalgia Press and then in a long serialisation in ... uh... was it the Menomenee falls Gazette (or one of the other imitations, 'Favourite Funnies' etc?... I confess i chopped them all up into loose sheets the better to transport the distilled essence in my travels, and even at that I no longer have them nearby). The late '80s and early '90s had the Flying Buttress reprints and now we are about to receive the IDW complete edition. I hope it does well and sees completion.

What appealed to me in Caniff was the humanity. take this sample which I found at Duckburg, two people talking about human stuff:

Caniff could have conversations go on for days, sparkling with lively patter. At other times, silent pictures speak eloquently, as in the oft reprinted final page of Terry, a variant of the romantic Bogart-Bergman parting at the end of Casablanca*. Caniff's page will always be a favourite of the comic strip aficionado for all that it evokes without the gloss of verbal description. It is the essence of all that we ever hoped to achieve with the form, when we started thinking of it as a 'form': a pictorial narrative language that is beyond cold theory, demonstrated long before we started looking for it.

It goes without saying of course that a biography of a guy who spent his entire life at his drawing board making some of the greatest comic strips ever including a series that lasted 41 years, written by a fellow enthusiast and obsessive compulsive like myself, would be intrinsically compelling to me. Harvey is good at pinning down once and for all the passage of assorted 'ghosts,' and art assistants through the life of the subject and his work (not as many as one would think in such a long span of time). For instance, one sequence reprinted in the old Steve Canyon mag from Kitchen Sink press, (edited by Dorf, mentioned above) that Caniff thought might have been ghosted by Fred Kida or Alex Kotsky is here given finally to William Overgard (of Mike Nomad fame). Such things are endlessly fascinating to me, but for those not of the same bent, the real interest is in the people of celebrity he knew and who knew him. A line from quite late in the book: Incongruously, one room of the jammed duplex became the resting place for the piano given to the Caniffs by Kurt Weill ; Bunny didn't want it at Vista Chino.

I thought of making a very short but comprehensive list of the serious biographies that we have of the great practitioners of our art, but this one stands on its own and I want to leave it standing like that for now. I'd like to say may Bob Harvey do more like this one, but the moment is too short. We're are lucky to have it at all.

(Update 4.04 pm. to add footnote.) * Not that they are so alike as they are going around in my head in a romantic swirl, much as they did twenty four years ago in the humid evening on the tarmac at Darwin airport (where Jane is headed, above) when I took the notion to propose to Anne, though we were in the terminal by the time I got the words out.



Anonymous Anonymous said...

Although being fair, we did listen attentively while you lovingly described how much you enjoyed both the book and subject.

And then we watched David Bowie perform Golden Years on the Soul Train. Sigh...

15 August 2007 at 01:46:00 GMT-5  
Blogger James Robert Smith said...

The saddest thing is that guys like Caniff who were once so important to the culture of the USA (and to a lesser extent that of all of the West) are now almost completely forgotten by the public who once adored the creations of Caniff and his contemporaries. Now their memories seem to be just made of fertile ground where movie adaptations are sometimes mined.

15 August 2007 at 16:47:00 GMT-5  
Blogger Hayley Campbell said...

I have that very book on my desk at the mo but it's ever so slightly different. The title logo isn't in red - it's a sort of transparent white and faintly yellow plastic.

It looks likes spunk, frankly, and the designer should be shot.

16 August 2007 at 03:58:00 GMT-5  
Blogger ADD said...


The designer's not to blame, the printer is. I believe Jacob Covey wrote about this mishap on the Fantagraphics blog a few weeks back.

16 August 2007 at 10:24:00 GMT-5  
Blogger Hayley Campbell said...

Ah! Good. There is one more person in the world with taste than I thought there was this morning. Apologies to the designer.

16 August 2007 at 10:46:00 GMT-5  
Blogger Eric Reynolds said...

What a lovely piece of writing, Eddie.

And yeah, it was the printer's fault for that spunky cover, not Jacob's! He's mortified by it. We reprinted the dustjacket properly and anyone who bought the book with the spunk version can contact Fantagraphics and get it replaced.

16 August 2007 at 13:09:00 GMT-5  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'd be interested to know what Mr. Campbell thinks about the politics of Steve Canyon.

Eddie mentions that the series "was seriously losing circulation" in the 70s, though he doesn't go into details about the reasons for this. How much did changing political sensibilities come into play?

16 August 2007 at 13:56:00 GMT-5  
Blogger Martin Wisse said...

You may say, 'all right, but we can't see any of that in your work, Campbell.' Fair observation.

Actually, now you've mentioned it, I can certainly see the influence of Caniff in your work, in compostion mostly.

16 August 2007 at 14:56:00 GMT-5  
Blogger Eddie Campbell said...

I bought my copy from Eric himself, who insisted I take a replacement cover. Thanks for the good words.

And as for the politics. It's a small mind indeed that can only commune with books that exactly mirror its own worldview.

Harvey is very good in his coverage of it all.

16 August 2007 at 16:09:00 GMT-5  
Blogger Eddie Campbell said...

."It's a small mind ..books that exactly mirror its own worldview."

For example, and relevant to my piece above, my atheism would not cause me to hesitate to describe the Psalms as one of the world's greatest and wisest literary works.

16 August 2007 at 18:08:00 GMT-5  
Blogger James Robert Smith said...

I'm often horrified by the beliefs of folk whose work I admire. But that doesn't blunt the quality of their work for me.

16 August 2007 at 20:17:00 GMT-5  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Coming across the site of 2007 Graphic Storytelling, I was reminded of this entry of yours. Do you plan to participate in that event?

19 August 2007 at 00:27:00 GMT-5  
Blogger Eddie Campbell said...


first i've heard of it. It does look good though. thanks for the link.
( I see my First Second editor mark Siegel is on the program)

19 August 2007 at 00:34:00 GMT-5  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home